Skip to main content

Click Fraud: It's More Than Just Cheating Competitors

What if I told you that I could be making $25 to several thousand dollars a month just by clicking on a bunch of online advertisements which I had no interest in?

Would you care?

What if I told you that some of these links I was clicking on were your links on which you're spending between $0.40 to $8.00 per click for?

Let me put it this way.....I could be stealing away your hard earned money and burning a hole in your ad spend budget.

I should have your complete attention by now.

Well, according to the cover story in the October 2nd 2006 issue of Business Week, an investigation has revealed "a thriving click-fraud underground that is populated by swarms of small-time players, making detection difficult."

And how easy is it these days to start making money off of click fraud? Too easy. A couple from Minnesota said they dabbled in click fraud last year and made more than $5,000. They employed a simple scheme in which they "set up dummy web sites filled with nothing but recycled Google and Yahoo advertisements. Then they paid others small amounts to visit the sites, where it was understood they would click away on the ads." They then split the resulting revenue generated from their dummy web site with the search engines.

With spending on internet ads growing faster than any other sector of the advertising industry and experts estimating that 10% to 15% of ad clicks are fake these days, you can start to see how click fraud is becoming a major issue.

But what makes up Click Fraud? Try these new terms on for size....

Parked Web Site: A site typically with little or no content except for lists of Internet ads, often supplied by Google or Yahoo; many of them are the source of false clicks.

Paid-To-Read: A PTR site pays members to look at other web sites and offers from marketers (ads); often used to generate false clicks on parked web sites.

Clickbot: Software that can be used to produce automatic clicks on ads; some versions employed in click fraud can mask the origin and timing of clicks.

Botnet: A collection of computers infected with software that allows them to be operated remotely; networks of thousands of mechanism's be used in click fraud.

Even though it sounds like some kind of sci-fi movie with all of these new high tech terms, how bad has click fraud actually become? The Business Week article talks about one Atlanta based businessman who estimates that click fraud has cost his company $100,000. On the other hand, a Russian software developer is making $10,000 a year from a clickbot he sells. And click fraud is so simple these these days that clickbots can be downloaded from the internet. The article states that "clickbots are popular among online cheats because they disguise a PC's unique numerical identification, or IP address, and can space clicks minutes apart to make them less conspicuous." It also states that "more skilled Chinese programmers modify the clickbots to outwit the American search engines (like Google and Yahoo)."

So what are the big search engines doing about click fraud? "Google and Yahoo say they can identify automated click fraud and discount advertisers bills accordingly." But advertisers have to prove that they are being cheated.

My question is, if clickbots are masking IP addresses, how is an advertiser supposed to prove they are being cheated?

I find it funny that as I'm writing this post, Google just released its earnings release. Once again, it was better than expected. Why? Because as I mentioned before, spending on internet ads are growing faster than any other sector of the advertising industry. And that means....more ads can be clicked. The more ads that are clicked, the more money search engines like Google and Yahoo make. And yet, click fraud is thriving more than ever.

But, I guess if more people are spending money to adverise with search engines, then apparently click fraud isn't a high priority issue for most advertisers.....

.....just don't tell the guy from Atlanta this!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hey retailers, it's time to step up your coupon game!

Hate to be the bearer of bad news retailers but I can't find your coupons online.  I've run countless coupon related searches (on all of the major search engines) for some of your largest brands such as Staples, Target, McDonalds, Home Depot, and CVS to name a few. To be quite honest, it's a lousy consumer experience. All I see are countless affiliate sites that claim to offer me coupons from the retailer but RARELY deliver.  Sites like Techbargains.com serve up links which you think will provide you with a coupon but all they do is redirect you to the retailer's home page.  I invite you to try it.  Click on one of the green 'Activate Coupon' buttons to access the particular coupon: http://www.techbargains.com/staplescoupons.cfm .  It tells you to 'Please wait while we activate your deal' as it downloads who knows what to your system.  Just when you get excited about being presented with a coupon that you can print out and take into the ret...

Monetizing Big Data In Yahoo Web Analytics

There's been a lot of talk/press already around Yahoo's new CEO, Scott Thompson, and his thoughts on big data at Yahoo.  Here are a few examples that have already been written since yesterday: Yahoo's New CEO Has Data Focus Can Yahoo's New CEO Thompson Harness Big Data Analytics? The Key To Yahoo's Long Term Health? Data, Says New CEO Rest assured though, Yahoo has some of the best big data geniuses around.  A company like Yahoo has to have some smart data guys when you're bringing in over 700 million monthly unique visitors to your properties each month.  Ever heard of Hadoop?  "The most well known technology used for Big Data is Hadoop. Hadoop is used by Yahoo, eBay, LinkedIn and Facebook. Google uses a proprietary version of Hadoop" And Hortonworks, a big data company that  spun out from Yahoo this past summer expects that "Half the worlds data will be on Hadoop in 5 years" So if Mr Thompson is looking to monetize "big d...

Analyzing Analyst Struggles

Raise your hand if you are an analyst and you've run into one of these issues before: Data Discrepancies:  Your stakeholder approaches you and says, "I noticed the data in your report doesn't match the data in this other report.  Which one is correct?" No Data:   Your stakeholder asks for some data but after some further research, you realize that product team never implemented the proper tracking.  Zero.  Zilch.  Nada. Blocked Access:   Your stakeholder asks for a dashboard that requires integration from multiple data sources.  You go to query the data but realize you don't even have access to one of the databases.   Ad Hoc Request Madness:   Multiple stakeholders ask for data, dashboards, and insights all at the same time.  And they want it yesterday. Groundhog Day Questioning:   Your stakeholders ask the same questions over and over and over again. Below I've laid out some of the Top Analyst Struggles along with the impacts ...